Stuart Keeler Stuart Keeler

Formability Rules from Mother Nature

December 1, 2013

Fig. 1—The bending operation will take the forming mode with the least energy consumption—a bend radius smaller than the punch radius.
Die-design handbooks, material textbooks, seminars, home-study courses, magazine articles and columns and a myriad of other sources, written by press-shop experts, professors, researchers and specialists in engineering, metallurgy and other related fields provide a wide breadth of useful information about metalforming. The laws of physics also should be included, but textbooks on this subject can be difficult to comprehend. Therefore, I’d like to provide some applicable laws written at a lower level of complexity—“The Rules from Mother Nature.”

Rule 1: Unless controlled by outside forces, sheetmetal will utilize any deformation mode that requires the least amount of total energy.

Fig. 2—Forcing the bend radius to maintain the punch radius requires extra energy, delivered through a stiff rubber pad driven by a spring or hydraulic cylinder.
As a simple example, consider bending sheetmetal over a punch of a given radius (Fig. 1). To meet part print, the material should wrap tightly around the punch or die. However, if it bends like a hinge (kinking), only a small segment of the sheet deforms. Compared to a larger segment of material conforming to the punch geometry, the bend mode requires less energy. This kinking can easily be detected by comparing actual bend radius to the required punch radius. When the workpiece material contains yield-point elongation, with upper and lower definable yield stresses and resulting Lüder’s bands, this tendency for independent bending increases greatly.

Rule 2: To change this independent forming mode, one must pay Mother Nature with additional energy added to the forming process.

For the bending problem in Fig. 1, metalformers typically apply a high-durometer rubber pad to the flat blank and force the pad to maintain blank-to-punch contact with a hydraulic cylinder or stiff spring (Fig. 2). The cylinder or spring contributes additional energy to the forming process, as required by Mother Nature.

Fig. 3—The die was adjusted to provide nearly zero springback for material A. When material B was placed in the same die without any process changes, severe sidewall curl resulted. Material B had a higher n-value and more workhardening. Courtesy of WorldAutoSteel—AHSS Application Guidelines ver. 4.0.
Rule 3: When the forming forces release, the stamping will take whatever shape it can to minimize residual stresses.

This shape change, called springback, can occur in several forms including angular change, sidewall curl, twist, global shape change and surface disturbances. Formed channels or beams are highly susceptible to sidewall curl (Fig. 3). Channel A was formed by a specific process designed for steel with 50-ksi yield strength and 65-ksi tensile strength. These numbers provide a rough estimate of the workhardening exponent (n-value).

Now observe the major sidewall curl in channel B. Yield strength equals that of channel A, but its tensile strength is higher. The TS/YS ratio for channel B is higher than channel A, indicating a different forming process, a higher n-value, and a stronger material exiting the forming process. The residual stress balance of channel A is lost as channel B seeks its own minimized residual stress forming mode.

Rule 4: Within the stamping, positive residual stresses must be balanced by negative residual stresses.

Fig. 4—While still in the die (A), the cup has complete circumferential compressive stresses. When released from the die (B), the upper portion of the cup expands to release the compressive stresses. The upper part then goes into tension to balance the residual compressive stresses still trapped in the cup.
Schematic A of Fig. 4 shows the elastic stresses in a deep-drawn cup while still in the forming die. The wall is created from sheetmetal originally in the blank. This material must compress as the circumference of the blank becomes smaller in its journey to the die radius. The material at the top of the cup must travel the furthest, and so must compress the most to create the largest compressive elastic stresses.

When we remove the cup from the die, these elastic stresses attempt to reach zero. However, the geometry of the cup only allows the cup circumference to increase (springback). The upper sections of the cup height are less constrained, allowing the elastic stresses to reach zero at the upper rim first. However, while the lower sections of the cup still have compressive stresses attempting to reach zero, they are more geometrically constrained. These lower zones force the upper zones to continue expanding, generating tensile elastic stresses (Fig. 4 schematic B). When the tensile elastic stresses balance the compressive elastic stresses, the cup stops changing shape.

Rule 5: Any subsequent modifications to the stamping will change the residual elastic stress state and therefore the shape of the stamping.

Redraw the cup, trim the top of the cup, punch a hole, weld on a bracket, heat the cup or any other modification and the cup will change the shape and residual-stress pattern. That is why stampings matching part print after the first form operation usually do not end up with the specified dimensions in the final product. Some post-forming operations can even create new elastic stresses that interact with the previous stresses for an unpredictable shape change. To compound the problem, we cannot see or measure these stresses—especially in the press shop. MF
Industry-Related Terms: Compress, Die, Tensile Strength, Twist, Form, Forming, Surface, Blank, Bend Radius, Bending
View Glossary of Metalforming Terms

Technologies: Quality Control


Must be logged in to post a comment.
There are no comments posted.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Start receiving newsletters.