Tooling by Design


 

SHARE:  

Metal Stamping Inconsistencies

By: Peter Ulintz

Thursday, January 1, 2015
 

Failure to recognize that the production of metal stampings is a highly interactive process consisting of many input variables, all of which must be controlled, contributes mightily to our process and dimensional inconsistencies.

The stamping process comprises more than 50 processes inputs—some studies have identified more than 100 inputs—that can affect part quality and dimensional stability. When problems arise, the stamping die, certainly one of many process input variables, often receives disproportionate and unnecessary attention. One example: Making adjustments inside the die to improve part flatness, when the real problem lies with improperly straightened coil material that releases trapped stress after the coil has been notched or punched.

Part-to-part inconsistency also may be caused by a sloppy press or ram slide that fails to repeat in distance and parallelism with each stroke; an inconsistent feed system that forces the pilots to correct strip location in both directions; or camber in the material that shifts the strip from side to side within short distances.

Other sources of part-to-part inconsistency:

Incoming Material

Stampers often blame the quality of the incoming material, sometimes with justification. However, the real problem may be how the purchasing manager orders the material, or his reluctance to pay a premium for the higher-quality material that the process requires.

Purchasing material with little technical information—ordering 1010 AKDQ steel, for example—allows for the supplier to provide a wide range of material properties. A low-carbon vacuum-degassed steel would fall into this specification, as well as a 1006 EDDQ material or a 1008 DDQ. All have less than 0.13-percent carbon content and all have been aluminum-killed. And, all will perform differently in the die.

It also may be necessary to purchase material with closer-than-standard thickness tolerances, a controlled yield-strength range or a minimum yield-to-tensile ratio to help process tight-tolerance stampings.

Straighteners and Feeders

Straighteners that inadequately straighten the incoming material may require frequent adjustments and complex tool compensation.

Stampers select from three basic types of coil-correction equipment: flatteners, precision straighteners and levelers. A five-roll flattener may not adequately remove coil crossbow, but a 13-roll precision straightener will. When crossbow causes quality problems in a particular stamping, constant die adjustments (from coil to coil and within a coil) will be required to maintain part quality if the incoming material is simply flattened. On the other hand, a precision straightener can work the incoming material hard enough so that it becomes flat, with minimum or no crossbow, and present the incoming material to the die consistently in this condition.

Stampers also can purchase stock feeders that practically eliminate the need for pilots in a die. And, some feeders will force pilots to work beyond their original intent. Not presenting the work accurately to the next event surely will result in inconsistencies of product as well as other problems, such as breakage and premature tool wear.

Press

Stamping-press motion is simple and basic. The ram (or slide) reciprocates down and up, causing the stamping tool to process the work material. What we often take for granted is that press repeatability in three-dimensional space (left-right, fore-aft, up-down) produces part consistency. Worn or sloppy gibbing, crankshaft bearings or pitman connections will produce inconsistency of the press and, consequently, of the parts being produced.

Don’t overlook how changes in process temperature can affect linear expansion of press members and die components. A press structure will change size as it warms to its normal operating temperature. And, in-die process heat (due to friction) can change the characteristics of punches and die sections by altering their original design size or clearances. When the press structure and die components change shape, the parts that they produce surely will be affected.

Lubrication

Press lubrication not only ensures press longevity but also contributes to process consistency. Process lubricants play a major role in the consistent quality of the parts being produced. In-process lubrication provides consistent friction and cooling conditions, important to ensure consistent part production and to prolong tooling life.

Lubricant type and viscosity, the amount applied and its location, and its operating temperature range all are critical factors. Most lubricants are specifically formulated to work within specific process-temperature ranges.

Design

Product and tooling design represent major contributors to stamped-part inconsistencies. Product designers often lack a thorough knowledge of what’s involved in producing the parts that they need and, consequently, introduce problems and inconsistency in the manufacture of those parts.

Tooling designs that cut corners to reduce tooling costs inevitably will produce inconsistency. It may not happen at die buy-off, but such designs eventually will be exposed. Examples include use of thin and weak sections that lack the rigidity needed to withstand long production runs; improper tooling materials that wear prematurely; improper cutting clearances; and inadequate or ineffective piloting that results in inconsistent part location. “Forming in air” is the term used to describe forming operations where the part is not rigidly held by a spring-loaded pressure pad prior to forming; this practice almost always causes inconsistency.

Progressive-die processes can be challenging, especially when trying to solve quality-related problems. Did the material feed properly? Are the pilots positioning the strip accurately? Is pitch length growing, so that the distance between the pilot holes exceeds design limits, or is it shrinking so that the distance between pilots is less than designed? Is a stretch flange splitting due to a mismatched cut, or are extrusions splitting due to a burr? Is the die hitting too hard or not hard enough? Are deep-drawn features splitting, due to restricted material flow or to an incorrectly specified radius? Is the carrier design appropriate? Is the die hitting level in all the stations? Is die timing correct with the die fully loaded? Do cutting clearances change with the die fully loaded due to tipping moments?

Achieving consistent part quality relates directly to how well pressroom personnel understand all of the stamping-process inputs. Our challenge: Identify those variables that contribute most to part-to-part variation, and control those variables to the best of our ability. MF

 

Related Enterprise Zones: Tool & Die


Reader Comments

Posted by: Rose Henderson on 2/10/2019 8:41:33 PM - URL: http://steelhemisphere.com/
I would imagine metal stamping is highly interactive. You need to make sure the process runs smoothly after all. Not only that, but I would imagine fixing a mistake on metal takes a lot more work to fix than some other materials. I suppose it would depend on the type of metal being used though.

Posted by: Sam Hall on 6/10/2015 7:07:48 PM - URL: http://www.hubmfg.com/capable.htm
It's really easy to point fingers at the most visible part of the process, but there's so much more going on. It may be a combination of multiple variables that's causing the discrepancies. It may be a bit more work initially to analyze and troubleshoot the cause of the problem, but it saves time and money in the long run.

Posted by: Rose Henderson on 2/6/2015 8:09:27 AM
I would imagine metal stamping is highly interactive. You need to make sure the process runs smoothly after all. Not only that, but I would imagine fixing a mistake on metal takes a lot more work to fix than some other materials. I suppose it would depend on the type of metal being used though. http://www.cmspinning.com/precision-metal-stamping-services.html

 

Post a Comment

* Indicates field is required.

YOUR COMMENTS * (You may use html to format)

YOUR NAME *
EMAIL *
WEBSITE

 

 

Visit Our Sponsors